One set, four training problems
Most tug purchases fail for a simple reason: the buyer picks one size and expects it to work for every dog and every drill. The Blue Herringbone Set — All 4 Tugs takes a different approach. It bundles four jute tugs (4x16, 5x20, 6x8, and 8x12) so you can match the tool to the dog in front of you, not force one tug into every session.
That variety matters because a puppy introducing bite work, a young dog building confidence, and an advanced working dog refining grip all need different bite surfaces. The set is built for professional bite work, motivational training, and drive development, with thick tubular handles and reinforced bound edges for repeated sessions. But it is not a chew toy — every tug in the set is an interactive training aid that requires human supervision.
What the set actually includes
- Blue Herringbone Set - All 4 Tugs: Includes all four sizes: Blue Herringbone Jute Tug 4x16, 5x20, 6x8, and 8x12. The four sizes let you progress a dog through different bite surfaces without buying separate tugs.

Blue Herringbone Set - All 4 Tugs - Blue Herringbone Set - All 4 Tugs: Specially woven Blue Jute with a poly core woven throughout for added strength and stability. The poly core reinforcement is what makes these tugs suitable for repeated bite work and tug games, not just light play.
- Blue Herringbone Set - All 4 Tugs: Two thick tubular handles on each tug for a secure, comfortable grip. Double handles give you better control during tug games, bite development, and reward-based training.
- Blue Herringbone Set - All 4 Tugs: All edges are lined and bound for a clean, reinforced finish. Bound edges stand up to demanding working dog training and interactive play better than unfinished jute.
Match the tug size to the training stage
The set's four sizes are not just spares — they are a progression. Use this as a starting point, then adjust to your dog's actual comfort and drive.
- Puppies and first bite work: Start with a smaller tug (the 4x16 or 6x8) to introduce the idea of gripping and tugging without overwhelming a young dog. The variety lets you find which surface your puppy naturally targets.
- Young dogs building confidence: Move to a mid-size tug (5x20) as your dog's grip and drive develop. The different bite surfaces in the set help you challenge the dog without jumping straight to the largest size.
- Advanced working dogs: The 8x12 gives experienced dogs a larger bite surface for professional bite work and drive development. Use it when the dog is already confident and you need to refine grip and engagement.
- Obedience and reward work: Any size in the set works as a reward toy for obedience training. Pick the size that fits comfortably in your hand and that your dog can grip cleanly during quick reward breaks.
Why jute and a poly core change the buying decision
Jute is a traditional material for bite tugs because it offers a firm, textured surface that dogs can grip confidently. The Blue Herringbone tugs use a specially woven blue jute with a unique herringbone pattern and a poly core woven throughout. That poly core adds strength and stability, which is why these tugs are described as heavy-duty and built for repeated training sessions.
The trade-off is honesty about use: jute tugs are interactive training aids, not chew toys. The catalog is explicit that dogs should not chew on or keep the tug after training sessions end. If you need a toy for unsupervised chewing, this set is the wrong purchase. If you need a durable bite tug for dog training with a handler on the other end, the materials are designed for exactly that.
Set vs. single tug: what you gain and what you pay
A single tug is cheaper upfront and simpler to store. The 4 piece tug set costs more but solves a problem single tugs cannot: you get four sizes without guessing which one your dog will work best on.
- Variety of bite surfaces: The set includes 4x16, 5x20, 6x8, and 8x12 — four distinct sizes for puppies, young dogs, and advanced working dogs. A single tug locks you into one surface.
- Progression without repurchasing: As your dog's skill and confidence grow, you can move up or down in size using tugs you already own. That is the main practical argument for the set.
- Storage and rotation: Four tugs take more space in your training bag. Rotating them also means you need a consistent place to keep them clean and separate from chew toys.
- Supervision requirement stays the same: Whether you buy one tug or four, these are supervised training aids only. The set does not change the handling rules.
A pre-purchase check before you order
Run through these checks so the set fits your training routine rather than sitting in a bag.
- Confirm your dog is ready for tug work: These tugs are designed for interactive training and reward use with a handler. If your dog is not yet comfortable gripping and tugging with you, start with foundational engagement work first.
- Plan for supervision only: The catalog states these are not chew toys and should always be used with human interaction and supervision. Do not allow your dog to keep the tug after sessions. Make sure everyone in the household follows that rule.
- Check the sizes against your dog: The set gives you 4x16, 5x20, 6x8, and 8x12. Think about which size your dog currently grips best and whether the next size up is realistic as training progresses.
- Decide where the tugs will live: Because they must not be left with the dog, plan a dedicated spot in your training bag or gear box, away from chew toys and out of your dog's reach between sessions.
What the supplied information does not settle
The catalog does not provide specific cleaning instructions for the Blue Herringbone tugs, so check the product page or contact ActiveDogs directly for care guidance before washing. It also does not list breed or weight recommendations for each size — the 4x16, 5x20, 6x8, and 8x12 measurements are the only size data supplied. Use those dimensions and your dog's current grip as your guide, and size up only when the dog is clearly ready.
If you are choosing between this set and a single tug, the decision comes down to whether you want one tool or a progression. The Blue Herringbone Set — All 4 Tugs is the more practical buy for trainers working multiple dogs or guiding one dog through stages. For a single dog already settled on one size, a single tug may be enough.

